|
'EXPERIENTIAL
CONCEPTUAL ANALYSISÔ ' (ECA) OR
‘PHASE 7 INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGNÔ
’- A THEORETICAL MODEL OF LEARNING
Ô
A Dissertation
Presented for the Glory of my Lord, Jesus
Christ
May I decrease, that He may increase in all
areas of my life and work!
By
Brett A. Peterson
Original submission, December 10, 1999
Phase 7
Published 2-2-2000
"The average Ph.D. thesis is nothing but
a transference of bones from one graveyard to another."
J. Frank Dobie
(1888–1964), U.S. author. A Texan in England, ch. 1
(1945).
I hope this work is an exception to the above
quote. My goal is to put the capstone on institutionalized
education and give you a new and fresh approach to education
that meets the needs of students and frees teachers to excel in
the 21st century.
Abstract
This dissertation presents a comparative
analysis of three teaching methods: traditional education -
consisting of memorization of facts, current teaching methods
(used in most college classrooms today) and ECA Phase 7 - the
instructional method developed in this research. ECA Phase 7 is
a new theory of learning based on this research and Biblical
learning methodologies. My research began on a philosophical
level in 1985 as I was developing a method of teaching for
myself. This study started on a scholarly level in 1996 and
relulted in theory development. I progressed towards the
development of a comprehensive interdisciplinary instructional
and learning model based on conceptual and experiential analysis
as a method of teaching and learning in the classroom
environment. This was completed in December of 1999.
As mentioned, the method developed in this
dissertation I have labeled "EXPERIENTIAL CONCEPTUAL
ANALYSIS" or 'ECA – Phase 7 Instructional Design'. It
analyzes and integrates various theoretical perspectives on
experiential and conceptual analysis studies and learning
methodologies from the disciplines of Biblical Psychology,
Sociology, Communication, Theology and historical learning.
A needs assessment, involving both
traditional memorization and conceptual ideation (ECA) methods
involved in fact disseminating activities was conducted to
determine elements in curriculum & instruction that would
prove most valuable for a new paradigm of education. This
information was used in designing a questionnaire comparing
traditional memorization and conceptual ideation (ECA) with
student’s perceptions and attitudes towards fact disseminating
learning methodologies used in education and measuring the
overall effectiveness of these activities. Data was collected by
qualitative and quantitative means utilizing a control group, a
traditional group, and one based upon ECA - Phase 7
methodological design. The questionnaire developed was both
controlled and open ended with the latter component designed to
add depth and quality to the quantitative portion of this
research.
Quantitative data was analyzed using
Spearman’s rho, Pearson’s correlation, cross tabulations,
means and frequency distributions. The qualitative information
was analyzed and displayed in descriptive display matrices. The
design used three groups of participants who were involved in a
twelve-week college course. Findings reveal clear results
regarding the effectiveness of ECA - Phase 7 learning
methodology developed in this research. Students in Calvary
Chapel Bible College and an almost equal number from Saddleback
College made up the control groups, the traditional groups
(memorization) and the conceptual groups (ECA). See figure 1 for
a brief matrix of the process evaluation and outcomes.
Although traditional studies and learning
methodologies of this century have been greatly influenced by
the disciplines of Psychology, Sociology, Communication,
Theology and historical learning, most models have emerged
unilaterally from their respective disciplines (as I will
demonstrate with an overview of each model later in this
treatise) and lack diversity, interrelatedness and richness of
complexity in both design and function. This research presents a
balanced theoretical and practical approach to education and
resulted in ECA - Phase 7 Instructional Design as a new method
of instruction and learning. This process produced a learning
framework and systems perspective with a vision towards
educational reform for the postmodern/ neoexperiential (I will
define this later, or turn to the glossary at the end of this
work) student. I also am giving teachers the tools needed to
move towards achieving a much needed paradigm shift.
This shift is, at a very basic level,
understanding the need for schools and classrooms (which I call
‘esoterically enhanced environments’ or ‘dynamic learning
classrooms’) to integrate traditional and cutting edge
epistemologies. ECA has been established in this research as a
catalyst for educational change and has shown its effectiveness
in the students and teachers as well.
It is with this dissertation I am attempting
to add depth to the educational system by adding dimensions to
the edges. Now some of my colleagues will call my work
‘fringe’ or even ‘cutting edge’. I see it more as
clarifying and adding depth to the classroom. Education, to this
point in time has been two dimensional – teachers present
knowledge, students take notes on knowledge presented and cram
for the test that is supposed to measure how well they learned
that knowledge. Utilizing ECA – Phase 7 methods, the teacher
adds depth and dimension to the classroom experience. Much like
Zeuxix, the first Greek painter who added shading to paintings
to give them a three dimensional look and for the first time
gave paintings a sense of reality. He painted Fifth century BC.
Now, 2,500 years later, I hope this method makes the educational
experience more ‘real’ to the students and adds a whole new
dimension to the instructional & learning process in the 21st
century.
Copyright Statement
and Trade Marks in this Dissertation
Copyright ã
’99,2002
Brett Peterson
All rights reserved.
The terms "experiential conceptual
analysis (ECA) as a method of teaching", "experiential
conceptual analysis (ECA) as a method of students to assimilate
facts", experiential conceptual analysisÔ
, ECAÔ , and "experiential
conceptual analysis (ECA) as a new framework to structure
College instruction", "Phase 7 Instructional DesignÔ
", "Phase 7Ô ",
"Phase 7 IDÔ ", "ECA-Phase
7Ô ", "visioneeringä
", "Core Motivated Learningä
" or CMLä , "dynamic
learning classroomsä " and
"Esoterically Enhanced EnvironmentsÔ
" or "EEE classroomsÔ
" are here in copyrighted and the trademarks of Brett
Peterson, and the intellectual property of the same. Any use of
these terms must refer back to the author and are reserved and
protected by the author of this dissertation and under US and
International copyright and trademark laws.
Additionally, ‘neo-experientialism’ or
‘post-deconstructualism’ as the successor to postmodern
thought are terms and concepts originated in this dissertation.
See the glossary for a concise definition.
Acknowledgments
First and foremost I want to thank my Lord
and Savior Jesus Christ, who gives me life, peace, and the great
hope of eternal life in Him. All I do is for the glory of God,
and I now clothe myself in humility and direct all praise to my
Father in heaven and His Son Jesus Christ. For it is by my
Lord’s grace and mercy that I was able to complete this
laborious work you now hold in your hand.
I gratefully acknowledge the support of
Pastor Gary Kusunoki, the elders, board, and congregation at
Calvary Chapel Rancho Santa Margarita, through which, I was
awarded the time and support to perform this research at the
Bible College in Rancho Santa Margarita, CA.
I am also gratefully indebted to those who
have helped shape my view on epistemology at Southern California
College / Vanguard University - including Professor Phil
Robinette, Ph.D., Professor William Williams, Ph.D., Professor
Vince Gill, Ph.D., & Professor Ronald Wright.
Special thanks to all the participants in
this study as well as a formal acknowledgment of your dedication
and determination in being a foundational part in building an
academically enhanced system of learning and teaching.
I would also like to acknowledge the people
in my personal life whose support and encouragement have
provided me with the inspiration needed in accomplishing this
research: Drew Segawa, the students of Calvary Chapel Bible
College in Rancho Santa Margarita, the board of directors of
Coastland Ministries (Larry and Eileen Eimermann & Mark and
Lorey Chew), and friends that are to many to mention.
Most of all, I want to thank my family for
never giving up hope in God to work in me His perfect will -
many thanks to my parents, Grant and Dee Peterson, Debora (my
sister) and her husband Danny and their daughter Sarah Hawley,
and of course my son Cody.
Finally, my most profound and heartfelt
thanks goes to my inspiration in life, the focus of my desire
and attention, my princess and my wife, Cheryl. Thanks for
putting up with the late nights and early mornings I spent
typing on the computer and studying – I could not have
accomplished this without your loving support!
"It is not enough for theory to describe
and analyze, it must itself be an event in the universe it
describes. In order to do this, the theory must partake of and
become the acceleration of this logic. It must tear itself from
all referents and take pride only in the future. Theory must
operate on time at the cost of a deliberate distortion of
present reality."
Jean Baudrillard
(b. 1929), French semiologist. The Ecstasy of Communication,
"Why Theory?" (1987).
Preface
A New World is emerging, and it is radically
different than the one our current educational system is based
on. With the advent of the Internet and CD computer technology,
knowledge and information is accessible to any student on any
subject from around the world! This was foreseen by the Prophet
Daniel in Daniel 12:3,4:
"3 And they that be wise shall shine as
the brightness of the firmament; and they that turn many to
righteousness as the stars for ever and ever. (sounds like a
teacher to me)
4 But thou, O Daniel, shut up the words, and
seal the book, even to the time of the end: for many shall run
to and fro (the idea in the Hebrew is to very quickly move
something back and forth – I would call this ‘jetsetting’),
and knowledge shall be increased." (in the Hebrew,
‘increased’ means exponentially added to and suggests an
almost supernatural increase – the only thing that could
fulfill this prophecy is the internet – which, in the mind of
a 6th century BC writer, the internet would be
‘supernatural’ in the way it has increased mankind’s
knowledge) KJV
In this ‘postmodern’ or
‘neoexperiential’ world (I will define this in chapter 5), I
observed a need for a paradigm shift on a foundational level
within our educational system – both for instructional and
learning methodologies. In the needs assessment of this
research, I found my observations were in fact confirmed.
Let me ask you a fundamental question right
in the beginning: Do you believe the same teaching methods used
before computers and the advent of the Internet is still
applicable to 21st century students? If you are
unsure, let me ask you another clarifying question: Do you
believe education before the printing press was different than
education after books became available? The answer is a profound
‘yes’!
Society has changed, students have changed,
the world has become connected, and knowledge has increased
exponentially via the access to that knowledge on the Internet,
and it is time to produce a significant shift in educational and
learning philosophy and methodology. This is why I was driven to
develop ECA – Phase 7 Instructional Design. I hope it will be
a catalyst for this paradigm shift to occur so that the needs of
the students in this 21st century can be met.
Let us press on to a bold New World of
instruction and classroom dynamics. Let us embrace change and
meet the needs of the students of this generation and beyond.
Let us catch the vision of instruction that will revolutionize
the way the classroom is used.
Come teachers, let us reason together, take
part in visioneering with me into the future of education and a
bold new way of instruction – Phase 7 Instructional Design is
at the forefront of this movement – dare to grow!
Brett Peterson,BA Religion, BA Sociology, MA
Education, MA Social Work, Ph.D. in Educational Research, &
most importantly, Servant of Jesus Christ.
"Education is the art of making man
ethical."
George Hegel
(1770–1831), German philosopher. The Philosophy of Right,
no. 58 (1821; tr. 1942).
|